Tablesetters: A Baseball Podcast

Dave Sims Exclusive Q&A, Mount Rushmore of Baseball’s Best Tablesetters, Pete Alonso’s Deal, Jack Flaherty to Tigers & Our NCAA Fandom Pledge | 60

Welcome to Episode 60 of Tablesetters! This week, we’re kicking things off with an exclusive and exciting Q&A featuring none other than legendary broadcaster Dave Sims! Through email exchanges, Dave gives us a rare behind-the-scenes look at life in the booth, reflecting on his incredible career and the journey that led him to his first season with the New York Yankees. From calling some of the most memorable moments in Seattle Mariners history to sharing insights on the art of broadcasting, Dave’s words are a must-hear for any baseball fan.
But that’s just the beginning—there’s plenty of offseason buzz to break down!
🔥 Pete Alonso’s two-year, $54 million deal with the Mets— We analyze what this means for Alonso’s future and the Mets’ direction.
🔥 Jack Flaherty to the Tigers on a two-year, $35 million deal—Can Detroit make a serious push in the AL Central with this addition to their rotation?
🔥 Gleyber Torres vs. Brian Cashman—Torres didn’t hold back after Cashman’s comments about his past tenure with the Yankees. We break down the drama and does it actually mean anything?
Then, we get into one of the most fun debates in baseball history—the Mount Rushmore of Tablesetters! These players aren’t just speedsters or leadoff hitters; they’re the ultimate catalysts, the ones who consistently get on base, disrupt pitchers, and set the stage for their teams to score. We discuss the greatest tablesetters of all time and how they shaped the game.
And here’s the big news—Steve & Devin are officially pledging their fandom to an NCAA baseball team for 2025! After much deliberation, Each of us on Tablesetters have chosen a squad to fully embrace this season. What went into our decisions? What makes these teams so exciting? We break it all down, plus what we’re looking forward to as we follow their journey this year.
Finally, we wrap things up with the latest trade rumors, player signings, and hot topics shaping the 2025 MLB season. Don’t miss out on Episode 60—it’s a packed one!
🎙️ Be sure to like, subscribe, and follow us on Instagram and Twitter @TablesettersPod for exclusive content, updates, and bonus discussions. Let’s talk baseball! ⚾🔥

Guest: Ben Upton (11Point7) | MLB The Show Adds College Baseball, Future MLB Stars, Golden Spikes Race & Schlossnagle’s Stunning Move | 59

College baseball is surging in popularity, and today, we’ve got the perfect guest to break it all down—Ben Upton, co-founder and host of 11Point7, the definitive podcast for college baseball coverage. Whether it’s unearthing the next MLB superstar, spotlighting powerhouse programs, or diving into the wild world of NIL and the transfer portal, 11Point7 has become a must-listen for fans of the game. And right now, college baseball is having a moment. For the first time ever, college teams are featured in MLB The Show 25. Programs like LSU, Texas, Tennessee, and Vanderbilt are in the game, with Road to the Show now starting at the amateur level. What does this mean for the sport? Could it be the push college baseball needs to grab more mainstream attention? With the 2025 MLB Draft on the horizon, who are the future big-league stars? We’re diving into the elite prospects to watch, the under-the-radar gems who could break out, and even looking back at last year’s draft to predict which 2024 draftees will become perennial All-Stars. Golden Spikes season is here, and the race for college baseball’s top individual honor is heating up. Who are the frontrunners, and which players could make a surprise run at the award? The impact of NIL and the transfer portal has changed the landscape of college sports, but how has it affected baseball? Are powerhouse programs strengthening their grip, or is it creating more parity across the country? More MLB prospects are reaching the big leagues faster than ever, and college baseball is playing a huge role in that development. Are we entering a new era where college players have the upper hand over high school draftees? One of the biggest coaching shakeups in recent memory rocked college baseball this offseason, with Jim Schlossnagle leaving Texas A&M for Texas. How did it all unfold, and what does it mean for both programs moving forward? We’re covering all this and more with Ben Upton. Be sure to follow him on X @Ben_Upton5 and check out 11Point7 for the best college baseball coverage. Stay locked in with TableSetters for more episodes, and follow us on Instagram and X @TableSettersPod.
TableSetters is a proud affiliate of Dugout Mugs! Check out their incredible lineup of baseball bat mugs, wine glasses, and more. Score big on your next purchase with Dugout Mugs! Use code TS10 at checkout and enjoy an exclusive 10% discount on their unique, baseball-inspired drinkware. Whether you're sipping from a classic bat mug, a wine barrel mug, or a shot glass made from the knob of a bat, Dugout Mugs are the perfect way to show off your love for the game. Don't miss this opportunity to elevate your collection—grab yours today and save with TS10!

Max Scherzer to the Blue Jays, MLB The Show 25 Cover Reveal, Cease/King Trade Rumors, Padres Legal Drama, & Would José Altuve Be the Shortest LF in MLB History? | 58

Welcome to Episode 58 of Tablesetters! We’ve got a lot to cover in today’s episode, including some major moves in the MLB offseason. Max Scherzer’s surprising signing with the Toronto Blue Jays, the reveal of MLB The Show 25 featuring three of the game’s rising stars, and a key trade between the Cubs and Astros are all on the table. Plus, the Padres find themselves in the midst of a significant internal dispute that could impact their future. Let’s dive right in. First up, Max Scherzer’s unexpected move to the Blue Jays has raised a few eyebrows. The three-time Cy Young winner, who had a difficult 2024 season, is now joining a veteran heavy Toronto rotation on a one-year, $15.5 million deal. Paired with the likes of Kevin Gausman and Chris Bassitt, Scherzer could provide the experience the Blue Jays need to take their postseason push to the next level. But with the team’s payroll nearing $273 million, it remains to be seen whether they’re done making moves — and the rumors surrounding Pete Alonso only add more intrigue. Next, we’re talking about the unveiling of MLB The Show 25, which features three of baseball’s brightest young talents on the cover: Paul Skenes, Elly De La Cruz, and Gunnar Henderson. These rising stars are making waves in the league and represent the future of the game. Skenes, the NL Rookie of the Year and Cy Young finalist; De La Cruz, the speedster who stole 60 bases; and Henderson, the young slugger for the Orioles, are all players to watch as they continue to shape the future of Major League Baseball. On the trade front, the Cubs made a significant move by acquiring veteran closer Ryan Pressly from the Astros. The 36-year-old right-hander, known for his steady performance in Houston, will help solidify Chicago’s bullpen as they aim for a deeper playoff run in 2025. In exchange, the Cubs sent young right-handed prospect Juan Bello and $5.5 million to Houston. This deal highlights the Cubs’ commitment to competing, but rumors suggest they’re not done yet — with talks of a potential Dylan Cease trade to further strengthen their rotation. And then there’s the ongoing situation with the Padres. The franchise is currently facing not just trade talks but a serious legal dispute that could have a major impact on the team’s future. A lawsuit filed by Sheel Seidler, widow of the late Padres owner Peter Seidler, is creating internal tension within the organization. This legal conflict could affect the Padres’ financial flexibility and their ability to make moves in the free-agent market. The drama in San Diego is far from over, and it could have lasting consequences for the direction of the team. We also have a fun question to ponder today: Could José Altuve be the shortest left fielder in MLB history if the Astros were to move him to the outfield? We dive into this hypothetical situation and what it would mean for the team. In the spirit of video games and MLB The Show 25, Devin asks Steve who his go-to Mario Kart character is — a fun conversation to add some gaming flavor to today’s episode! We’ll be breaking down all these stories and more in today’s episode, so stay tuned for in-depth analysis. Don’t forget to follow us for exclusive updates and behind-the-scenes content on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod. And if you enjoy the show, make sure to like, subscribe, and share — your support helps us keep bringing you the latest MLB news.

Guest: Chris Welsh aka The Welsh (FantasyPros, BettingPros, Prospect One, In This League) | Fantasy Baseball Draft Insights & Strategy Trends | 57

Welcome to Episode 57 of Tablesetters! Today, we’re thrilled to be joined by Chris Welsh aka The Welsh, the mastermind behind In This League, a dynamic podcast network delivering expert insights into fantasy sports. Chris is also a prominent host and analyst for FantasyPros and BettingPros, as well as the creator of The Prospect One Podcast, where he provides an in-depth look at baseball prospects. Whether you’re a fantasy baseball veteran or just diving in, Chris’ expertise is a game-changer. Follow him on X @IsItTheWelsh.
We kick off with Chris sharing how many mock drafts he’s already tackled this offseason and dive into his thoughts on early rankings. While Shohei Ohtani, Aaron Judge & Bobby Witt Jr. are consensus top picks, Chris discusses his choice for the top of drafts and how that changes in keeper or dynasty formats.
From there, we explore the nuances of draft strategies for points leagues versus category leagues, how keepers influence redraft leagues, and what platforms Chris prefers for fantasy baseball. Plus, he shares insights on catchers, closers, and relievers—often overlooked but critical components of a winning roster.
Hot topics include the impact of Blake Snell transitioning to LA’s catching situation, breakout candidates for 2025, and players to avoid. Chris also sheds light on prospects to watch this season and beyond, including his favorite sleeper pick.
The conversation heats up as we explore underrated trends in fantasy baseball, the influence of Juan Soto’s move to the Mets, and how scenery changes could impact fantasy value. Chris even shares some bold predictions for the 2025 fantasy baseball season.
Before we wrap, Chris offers invaluable advice for managers gearing up for draft season and gives us a sneak peek into what’s next for In This League, FantasyPros, and The Prospect One Podcast.
Follow us for more: 📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod 🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
If you enjoy the episode, don’t forget to like, subscribe, and share. Let’s keep the conversation going—drop your fantasy baseball questions in the comments!

Ichiro, Sabathia, & Wagner Elected to Hall of Fame, Blue Jays Sign Santander, Dodgers' Bullpen Depth | 56

Welcome to Episode 56 of Tablesetters! This week, we’re diving deep into the latest MLB news, including Hall of Fame inductions, major signings, and updates from key teams as the offseason continues.
We kick things off with the exciting news of Ichiro Suzuki, CC Sabathia, and Billy Wagner being elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame. Ichiro’s near-unanimous selection, Sabathia’s dominant career, and Wagner’s elite closer status make this a class to remember. We reflect on their legendary careers and what their inductions mean for the game of baseball.
Next, we break down the Blue Jays' big offseason move, signing Anthony Santander to a five-year, $92.5 million deal. We discuss how this addition strengthens Toronto’s lineup, adds power, and creates flexibility, as well as the team's remaining potential targets despite the hefty contract.
On the Dodgers’ front, we analyze the state of their bullpen, including Michael Kopech’s forearm inflammation and the team's cautious approach as they bolster their relief options with Tanner Scott, Kirby Yates, and Blake Treinen. We explore the depth and flexibility they have in place to maintain a strong bullpen and cover potential injuries.
Follow us for more:📸 Instagram: @TableSettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TableSettersPod
If you enjoy the episode, please like, subscribe, and share—it makes all the difference as we continue to bring you in-depth baseball analysis!

Guest: Matt Devine (Devine Sports Gospel) | Roki Sasaki, Padres Offseason, Ownership Drama, Cease Trade Rumors, & Machado vs. Tatis vs. Merrill MVP Futures | 55

Welcome to Episode 55 of Tablesetters! Today, we’re joined by Matt Devine, one of the voices behind Devine Sports Gospel, your go-to source for all things San Diego Padres. Known for his humor and sharp takes, Matt is a must-follow for Padres fans. Be sure to check out his Instagram @DevineSportsGospel and X @DevineGospel for all the latest updates and bold opinions.
We kick things off with a look at how Devine Sports Gospel came to be. Matt takes us behind the scenes of the platform’s origin story and what makes it such a unique voice in Padres fandom. From there, we dive into the recent Roki Sasaki signing. Just before the deal with the Dodgers went down, Devine Sports Gospel stirred up some conversation about how Dodgers fans would feel if they missed out on Sasaki. With the signing official, we reflect on the drama that led to Sasaki’s move to LA.
Next, we pay tribute to the late Peter Seidler, whose impact on Padres fans and the San Diego community was immense. Matt shares his thoughts on Seidler’s legacy and what it means for the Padres' future. Speaking of the future, we discuss the Padres’ ongoing ownership drama and what it could mean for the team’s direction.
We shift gears to the 2024 NLDS, where the Padres led the Dodgers 2-1. Matt shares his thoughts on the thrilling energy and the decision to start Dylan Cease on three days’ rest in Game 4. Then we dig into trade rumors surrounding Dylan Cease and Robert Suarez and how these moves could affect the Padres' 2025 roster. Plus, Matt gives his take on whether the Padres are better off with Luis Arraez after watching him up close.
The Padres’ offseason has been tough, with WAR projections remaining flat. Matt talks about the moves he hopes for before Spring Training and whether he sees a silver lining. Then, we play a fun "life depends on it" game: Who’s more likely to win an MVP in the next few years—Manny Machado, Fernando Tatis Jr., or Jackson Merrill? Matt’s answer is sure to spark some debate!
We also look to the future of the Padres, with Matt sharing which prospect excites him the most. Plus, we discuss the rumored tension between Juan Soto and Manny Machado—was it well-known locally? Matt offers his perspective.
In a lighter moment, Matt shares the hilarious backstory behind his comment about throwing Lemonheads at Brian Giles after a social media comparison with Juan Soto.
Finally, we reflect on Joe Musgrove’s iconic shiny ear moment from the 2022 playoffs. Matt gives his take on that unforgettable sight.
We wrap it all up with a fun question: who makes Matt’s Mount Rushmore of San Diego athletes and why?
Follow us for more:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
If you enjoy the episode, like, subscribe, and share to keep the conversation going!

Remembering Bob Uecker, Rich Get Richer as Dodgers Land Roki Sasaki & Mets Prepare for Life Without Alonso | 54

Welcome to Episode 54 of Tablesetters! This week, we’re diving into the latest MLB news and major offseason moves. From the passing of broadcasting legend Bob Uecker to big signings and looming contract negotiations, we’ve got it all covered.
We begin with the somber news of Bob Uecker’s passing at 90. The beloved voice of the Milwaukee Brewers for over 54 years, Uecker’s humor, charm, and storytelling made him a national treasure, transcending the sport of baseball. His legacy lives on through two statues at Miller Park and his Hall of Fame induction in 2003. We reflect on his impact and the void left in the baseball world.
Next, we break down the Dodgers’ blockbuster signing of Japan’s top pitching prospect, Roki Sasaki. Sasaki’s triple-digit fastball and devastating splitter add another elite arm to an already stacked Dodgers rotation, featuring Shohei Ohtani, Yamamoto, and Blake Snell. But his decision to join Los Angeles is a tough blow for both the Padres and Blue Jays. We discuss how this move reshapes the NL West and what it means for the Dodgers’ title aspirations.
The Dodgers continue to dominate the headlines, with the signing of Tanner Scott to a four-year, $72MM deal. The high-powered lefty reliever adds depth to an already elite bullpen, which could help propel Los Angeles toward another championship run. We analyze Scott’s career trajectory and what this deal means for the Dodgers' future payroll.
We also take aim at the Dodgers' deferring payroll, questioning whether this trend is detrimental to baseball in the long term. We dive into how such financial maneuvers impact the sport’s competitive balance and whether it’s setting a troubling precedent for other teams.
In other team news, the Mets made waves with their two-year, $22MM acquisition of A.J. Minter, bolstering their bullpen with a dynamic southpaw. We also discuss the Mets’ moves regarding Pete Alonso, as contract talks hit a roadblock, and what this means for the team’s long-term outlook.
Finally, we reflect on the Cubs' payroll struggles, as owner Tom Ricketts responds to fan complaints about the team’s spending. With a budget nearing $220MM, we analyze the Cubs' offseason moves and their potential impact on the team's chances in 2025.
Follow us for more:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
If you enjoy the episode, please like, subscribe, and share—it makes all the difference as we continue to bring you in-depth baseball analysis!

Guest: Mike Petraglia (Code Reds) | Terry Francona Takes Over, Gavin Lux’s Role, Elly De La Cruz’s Billion-Dollar Potential, & Reds’ 2025 Outlook | 53

Welcome to Episode 53 of Tablesetters! This week, we’re joined by Mike Petraglia, host of Code Reds, the Cincinnati Reds podcast by CLNS Media. A seasoned journalist with years of experience covering the Reds, MLB, and beyond, Mike offers invaluable insights into Cincinnati’s outlook for 2025. Follow him on X @Trags for his expert commentary.
We begin with the Reds’ most significant offseason move: the hiring of Terry Francona as manager. What impact will Francona’s leadership bring to the team’s culture and playoff aspirations? Mike shares his thoughts on how this hire could signal a transformative era for the franchise.
Next, we analyze the acquisition of Gavin Lux. Could he take over at second base, and how might this affect Matt McClain’s role as he returns from injury? We explore the implications for the infield and beyond.
The Reds’ pitching staff is also in focus. With Hunter Greene at the forefront and additions like Brady Singer and Rhett Lowder strengthening the rotation, what key factors will determine their success? Plus, we examine the potential impact of Carlos Estevez on the bullpen and his fit alongside Alexis Díaz.
Elly De La Cruz remains the Reds’ centerpiece. Could he be the player to redefine the future of MLB contracts? We discuss his immense potential, areas for growth, and whether an extension might already be in the works.
We also reflect on the returns of Noelvi Marte and Christian Encarnacion-Strand, Chase Burns’ rise as a pitching prospect, and the lasting legacy of Pete Rose following his passing.
Lastly, we consider the Reds’ chances of capturing the NL Central crown. Who presents the bigger challenge—the Cubs or the Brewers? Mike also shares the offseason move he wishes the Reds had made, his most memorable moment covering the team, and his Cincinnati sports Mount Rushmore.
Follow us for more:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
If you enjoy the episode, please like, subscribe, and share—it makes all the difference as we continue to bring you in-depth baseball analysis.

Mount Rushmore of Role Players, Sasaki Sweepstakes Heating Up, & Offseason Moves to Watch | 52

Welcome to Episode 52 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back with another jam-packed show, blending offseason buzz with some nostalgic fun as they unveil their “Mount Rushmore of Baseball Role Players.” These are the unsung legends—players who didn’t dominate the headlines but left an indelible mark with their clutch performances, versatility, and leadership. Whether you’re a fan of gritty utility players, defensive specialists, or clutch postseason heroes, this segment is for you. But first, the MLB offseason is delivering plenty of drama. Japanese sensation Roki Sasaki has captured the league’s attention as the final stretch of his free-agency decision approaches. With the Yankees, Mets, Cubs, and Giants officially out of the running, the Dodgers, Padres, and Blue Jays have emerged as the frontrunners. Sasaki’s emphasis on player development and fit over financial incentives makes this decision one of the most fascinating in recent memory. Elsewhere, teams across the league are making moves to reshape their rosters. The Orioles are building up their bullpen with the addition of Andrew Kittredge, while the Pirates made headlines by signing Dominican prospect Darrell Morel to a $1.8 million bonus. From key bullpen additions and promising prospects to big-market teams pivoting their strategies, this offseason is shaping up to be a pivotal one for 2025. We’ll also explore rumors about player movement, including potential reunions and blockbuster deals that could shake up the standings. Don’t miss this week’s deep dive into the latest offseason storylines and our celebration of baseball’s greatest role players. Be sure to follow us for exclusive content and updates on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod!

Alonso Thinks He’s a Prince, Rooker’s $60M Extension, Lux Traded to Reds, & Dodgers Sign Hyeseong Kim | 51

Welcome to Episode 51 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back with a jam-packed MLB offseason update, offering you the latest trade rumors, blockbuster signings, and strategic moves that are shaping the 2025 season. The winter's been buzzing with activity, and we've got all the inside scoop! Pete Alonso's free-agent future is a hot topic, with Scott Boras reportedly using Prince Fielder’s 9-year, $214 million deal as a benchmark for what Alonso might command. With interest from teams like the Blue Jays, the stakes are high—will Alonso get the payday he’s dreaming of, or is reality setting in? Meanwhile, the Blue Jays are reportedly nearing a 4-year, $80 million agreement with outfielder Anthony Santander, addressing a critical hole in their lineup. Will this move help push Toronto closer to contention? In Los Angeles, the Dodgers have been making bold moves, signing Korean infielder Hyeseong Kim to a 3-year, $12.5 million deal with a potential extension option. But that’s not all—after signing Kim, they’ve also sent Gavin Lux to the Reds in exchange for outfield prospect Mike Sirota and a Competitive Balance draft pick. The Dodgers are making moves to stay on top of the NL West, and we’re here for it! The Oakland A’s have also been busy, locking up Brent Rooker to a 5-year, $60 million extension with an option for a sixth year. With this deal, the A’s are signaling a long-term commitment to their future—are they finally turning the corner after years of rebuilding? On the pitching front, the Baltimore Orioles have bolstered their rotation, bringing in veteran right-hander Charlie Morton on a one-year, $15 million contract. Is that all that they plan to do? In New York, the Yankees made a major splash by signing Max Fried, but now they're looking to trade Marcus Stroman. With the Blue Jays rumored to be the frontrunners, could a return to Toronto be in the cards for Stroman? Elsewhere, the Padres are caught in a legal battle over ownership control, as a lawsuit following Peter Seidler’s passing puts the future of the franchise in question. Meanwhile, the Rangers have strengthened their bullpen with Chris Martin on a one-year deal, and the Royals have added Michael Lorenzen to their staff for one season at $7 million. And don’t forget, potential trade talks involving Luis Castillo are heating up, with the Mariners and Orioles both in the mix. Where will Castillo land, and what could this mean for both teams’ playoff hopes? We’ll dive into all these moves and more in today’s episode. Stay tuned for in-depth analysis and be sure to follow us for exclusive content on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod!