Tablesetters: A Baseball Podcast

Alonso Thinks He’s a Prince, Rooker’s $60M Extension, Lux Traded to Reds, & Dodgers Sign Hyeseong Kim | 51

Welcome to Episode 51 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back with a jam-packed MLB offseason update, offering you the latest trade rumors, blockbuster signings, and strategic moves that are shaping the 2025 season. The winter's been buzzing with activity, and we've got all the inside scoop! Pete Alonso's free-agent future is a hot topic, with Scott Boras reportedly using Prince Fielder’s 9-year, $214 million deal as a benchmark for what Alonso might command. With interest from teams like the Blue Jays, the stakes are high—will Alonso get the payday he’s dreaming of, or is reality setting in? Meanwhile, the Blue Jays are reportedly nearing a 4-year, $80 million agreement with outfielder Anthony Santander, addressing a critical hole in their lineup. Will this move help push Toronto closer to contention? In Los Angeles, the Dodgers have been making bold moves, signing Korean infielder Hyeseong Kim to a 3-year, $12.5 million deal with a potential extension option. But that’s not all—after signing Kim, they’ve also sent Gavin Lux to the Reds in exchange for outfield prospect Mike Sirota and a Competitive Balance draft pick. The Dodgers are making moves to stay on top of the NL West, and we’re here for it! The Oakland A’s have also been busy, locking up Brent Rooker to a 5-year, $60 million extension with an option for a sixth year. With this deal, the A’s are signaling a long-term commitment to their future—are they finally turning the corner after years of rebuilding? On the pitching front, the Baltimore Orioles have bolstered their rotation, bringing in veteran right-hander Charlie Morton on a one-year, $15 million contract. Is that all that they plan to do? In New York, the Yankees made a major splash by signing Max Fried, but now they're looking to trade Marcus Stroman. With the Blue Jays rumored to be the frontrunners, could a return to Toronto be in the cards for Stroman? Elsewhere, the Padres are caught in a legal battle over ownership control, as a lawsuit following Peter Seidler’s passing puts the future of the franchise in question. Meanwhile, the Rangers have strengthened their bullpen with Chris Martin on a one-year deal, and the Royals have added Michael Lorenzen to their staff for one season at $7 million. And don’t forget, potential trade talks involving Luis Castillo are heating up, with the Mariners and Orioles both in the mix. Where will Castillo land, and what could this mean for both teams’ playoff hopes? We’ll dive into all these moves and more in today’s episode. Stay tuned for in-depth analysis and be sure to follow us for exclusive content on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod!

Corbin Burnes to Arizona, Teoscar Hernández Stays with Dodgers | Bregman to Tigers?, Santander’s Future | 50

Welcome to Episode 50 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back with a packed MLB offseason update, filled with blockbuster signings, trade rumors, and teams making bold moves for 2025! The Arizona Diamondbacks just made a statement, signing Corbin Burnes to a 6-year, $210 million deal with an opt-out after two seasons. This sets their payroll at a record $190 million and positions them as contenders in a tough NL West. But don’t count out the trade rumors — Jordan Montgomery could still be on the move. Meanwhile, the Los Angeles Dodgers keep their playoff hopes alive by re-signing Teoscar Hernández to a 3-year, $66 million deal. With other teams like the Mets and Blue Jays in the mix, this deal gives LA even more firepower for 2025. Over in Detroit, the Tigers are all-in on Alex Bregman, hoping to make him their third baseman. With Gleyber Torres already signed for 2025, the Tigers are positioning themselves to compete with their young core, but will Bregman seal the deal? In Washington, the Nationals have made modest moves, signing Josh Bell and Trevor Williams, but fans are hoping for more. Can they do enough to support their rising stars? Also, Anthony Santander is drawing interest from the Angels, Blue Jays, and Tigers, with a projected 4-year, $80 million deal. The Giants are also lurking for Pete Alonso, who turned down a 3-year, $90 million extension from the Mets. Where will Alonso land? Finally, the Angels are the most improved team this offseason (+6.4 fWAR), while the Padres have taken a significant hit (-10.4 fWAR). Or are they? We’ll break down what these shifts mean for the 2025 season. Stay tuned for more offseason insights, and don’t forget to follow us for exclusive content on Instagram and X @TablesettersPod!

Remembering Rickey Henderson, Buehler to Beantown, First Base Facelifts & More Offseason Moves | 49

Welcome to Episode 49 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back with all the latest MLB offseason news, from the loss of one of the game’s greatest players to significant trades and signings that are shaping the 2025 season. We begin by honoring the life and career of Rickey Henderson, the all-time stolen base king, who tragically passed away at the age of 65. Remembered for his incredible speed, plate discipline, and impact on the game, Henderson leaves behind a legacy that will never be forgotten. His longtime friend and teammate Dave Winfield confirmed the news, and we reflect on Rickey’s unparalleled contribution to the sport, from his historic career with the Athletics, Blue Jays, and others, to his iconic postseason moments. Turning our attention to the offseason, the Red Sox have made a big move, signing Walker Buehler to a one-year, $21.05 million contract. Buehler, whose career has been on a rollercoaster ride since undergoing Tommy John surgery, showed signs of his former dominance during the 2024 postseason, including 10 scoreless innings. If he can return to full form, he could be a game-changer for the Red Sox, who are still looking to add more pieces for their 2025 roster. Meanwhile, the Rangers have strengthened their lineup by signing Joc Pederson to a two-year, $37 million deal. Pederson’s left-handed power was a much-needed addition, addressing the team’s hole at designated hitter. With their recent additions, including Jake Burger and Kyle Higashioka, the Rangers are aiming for a more potent offense to complement their pitching staff. The Astros also made a significant move, signing Christian Walker to a three-year, $60 million contract. With first base an area of concern after a lackluster 2024 campaign from Jose Abreu and Jon Singleton, Walker brings defensive prowess and consistent offensive production. His arrival signals the Astros’ continued commitment to staying competitive as their payroll surpasses the luxury tax threshold for the second consecutive year. Elsewhere, the Phillies have bolstered their pitching staff by acquiring Jesús Luzardo from the Marlins in exchange for top prospects. Luzardo, now slotted as the No. 2 starter behind Zack Wheeler, adds much-needed depth to a Phillies rotation that’s hoping to contend for another postseason berth. Meanwhile, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is reportedly seeking a record-breaking contract extension from the Blue Jays, turning down their current $340 million offer in favor of a deal closer to the $500-$600 million range. This will undoubtedly be one of the offseason’s biggest storylines as the Jays are under increasing pressure to meet his demands or risk losing their superstar in the near future. As the offseason heats up, one of the most exciting international stories is Roki Sasaki, the Japanese pitching sensation drawing significant interest from MLB teams. Known for his perfect game in 2022 and his dominance in NPB, Sasaki is poised to make a big impact once he makes his MLB debut, and teams like the Rangers, Giants, Yankees, and Mets are all in the mix for his services. The Marlins are continuing their rebuild, focusing on player development and long-term sustainability. With moves like trading Luzardo to the Phillies, they’re looking to build a future that prioritizes young talent and a more stable payroll structure. In other news, the Rays have taken a low-risk gamble by signing Eloy Jimenez to a minor league deal. Despite his struggles in 2024, Jimenez’s potential bat could give the Rays an added offensive boost if he returns to form in 2025. We also take a look at the luxury tax picture, with nine MLB teams exceeding the $237 million threshold in 2024. This includes the Dodgers, Mets, and Yankees, who will face draft pick penalties and other financial consequences as a result. We break down what this means for the landscape of the offseason and how it could impact these teams’ future moves. Finally, we turn our attention to the Mets, who have been extremely active this offseason. After signing Juan Soto, the Mets are looking to further solidify their roster, with a potential trade for Pete Alonso still on the table. Their pitching staff has also seen some changes, with new additions like Sean Manaea, Frankie Montas, and Clay Holmes strengthening their rotation for 2025. Stay tuned for more offseason updates, predictions, and insights you won’t hear anywhere else. Don’t forget to follow us on Instagram and Twitter for exclusive content!

Cubs Land Kyle Tucker, Yankees Add Cody Bellinger & Devin Williams, Orioles’ “Vanity Project” Exposed? | 48

Welcome to Episode 48 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back to bring you all the latest MLB offseason news, from blockbuster trades and acquisitions to rumors and predictions shaping the 2025 season. We kick things off with the Cubs making a huge splash, acquiring three-time All-Star Kyle Tucker in a trade with the Houston Astros. We discuss what Tucker brings to Chicago’s lineup, how the Astros are retooling, and what this means for the Cubs' roster, including their decision to move 2019 NL MVP Cody Bellinger to the Yankees. Bellinger, along with $5 million to offset his contract, will play center field for New York, allowing Aaron Judge to return to right field as the Yankees look to replace Juan Soto’s bat in the middle of their lineup. Meanwhile, the Yankees continued their busy offseason by strengthening their bullpen with the acquisition of Devin Williams from the Brewers in exchange for Nestor Cortes. We break down what this means for New York’s pitching staff and their ongoing search for a first baseman, with Pete Alonso and Christian Walker emerging as key targets. Next, we dive into the Jack Flaherty market. Coming off a strong 2024 campaign, Flaherty is drawing interest from teams like the Orioles, Red Sox, Mets, and Cubs. But will Baltimore’s “vanity project” under GM Mike Elias hold them back? Sources report that Elias is reluctant to spend big in free agency despite new owner David Rubenstein’s willingness to open the checkbook. This comes as the Orioles lose key pieces like Corbin Burnes and Anthony Santander to free agency. We discuss how Baltimore’s unwillingness to make major moves—and the apparent tension within their front office—could shape their 2025 season, especially with Corbin Burnes reportedly in “serious talks” with the Giants. Don’t miss out on all this action! We’ve got it covered, plus bold predictions and insights you won’t hear anywhere else. 📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod
🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod

Guest: Joey Copponi (ITM Podcast) | Garrett Crochet Acquisition, Red Sox Offseason Plans, Juan Soto's $700M Offer, Trade Talks, & the Future of Rafael Devers | 47

Welcome to Episode 47 of Tablesetters, your go-to podcast for all things baseball! This week, we’re thrilled to welcome Joey Copponi, co-host of the ITM Podcast, where he delivers fresh insights and in-depth analysis on everything surrounding the Boston Red Sox.
We kick things off with today’s big news: the Red Sox’s acquisition of Garrett Crochet from the White Sox. The hard-throwing left-hander immediately strengthens Boston’s rotation, adding a controllable arm with big upside as the team looks to position itself for a serious playoff push. Joey joins us to break down how Crochet fits into the Red Sox’s pitching mix, what this move signals about Boston’s strategy, and whether this could be the start of a bigger offseason spending spree.
From there, we dive into the Red Sox’s reported $700 million offer to Juan Soto. This eye-popping number raises serious questions about the team’s approach and their confidence in the current championship window. Was Boston prepared to go all-in on Soto to solidify their lineup for the next decade, or was this bold offer speaking to a broader shift in how the front office operates? Joey shares his perspective on what this pursuit means for the Red Sox’s future.
We also tackle Boston’s rumored trade discussions with the Seattle Mariners, particularly the potential of moving Triston Casas for young pitching talent like Bryce Miller or Bryan Woo. Is it worth sacrificing a cornerstone bat to bolster the rotation? And if Casas does move, how might that impact the infield, especially with Rafael Devers potentially shifting away from third base?
The conversation heats up as we explore the Red Sox’s growing interest in international star Roki Sasaki. Adding the Japanese ace to the mix would be a game-changing move for Boston’s rotation. We also revisit their pursuit of Teoscar Hernández, breaking down how the team’s search for a right-handed power bat has intensified now that Tyler O’Neill has signed with the Orioles. Joey weighs in on realistic targets the Red Sox could pursue to fill that gap.
Finally, we discuss the possibility of Alex Bregman joining the Red Sox and what that move might mean for the lineup and defensive structure. Joey also gives his take on the ripple effects of Jarren Duran’s breakout season and how it has raised expectations for prospects like Kristian Campbell, Roman Anthony, and Marcelo Mayer as the Red Sox look to their next generation of talent.
It’s a packed episode filled with bold takes, deep analysis, and plenty of Red Sox chatter that fans won’t want to miss.
Follow us for the latest updates and exclusive content:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
Support the show by liking, subscribing, and sharing — your support helps us grow and continue to bring you the best baseball content!

Max Fried to the Yankees, Red Sox Trade for Garrett Crochet & Kyle Tucker Rumors Heat Up | 46

Welcome to Episode 46 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are back to bring you up to speed on all the latest MLB offseason buzz, with major signings, blockbuster trades, and swirling rumors that are reshaping the landscape of the league.
We kick things off with the New York Yankees making a huge splash, signing star left-hander Max Fried to a monster 8-year, $218 million deal. With Fried now anchoring their rotation alongside Gerrit Cole, the Yankees are making a clear statement. But does this move cement them as the team to beat in the ultra-competitive AL East? Devin and Steve dive into the ripple effects this deal could have on the division.
Meanwhile, the Boston Red Sox made waves of their own, striking a bold trade to acquire White Sox lefty Garrett Crochet. Boston parted with highly touted prospects Kyle Teel and Braden Montgomery to get their guy, but did they give up too much for a pitcher with untapped potential or not enough? We break down the risk, reward, and what this means for the Red Sox’s future.
Trade rumors are also heating up around Kyle Tucker, the Astros’ star outfielder. Could Tucker truly be on the move? If so, which teams are realistic landing spots, and how might this shake up Houston’s roster-building strategy as they aim to stay atop the AL West?
But the headlines don’t stop there! Japanese phenom Roki Sasaki has officially been posted, and MLB teams are already scrambling to land the ace who could become a franchise cornerstone. Where might Sasaki land, and what does this mean for the international pitching market?
Plus, we break down:
Nathan Eovaldi re-signing with the Texas Rangers — what does this mean for their quest to get back to the World Series? Andres Gimenez heading north to the Toronto Blue Jays — how does he fit in their plans? The Washington Nationals winning the MLB Draft Lottery and securing the No. 1 pick for 2025 — what does this mean for the window opening to contend?
It’s a jam-packed episode filled with analysis, insight, and bold predictions as Devin and Steve dissect all the offseason action!
Don’t miss out on this week’s episode — make sure to subscribe and follow for all the latest updates:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod

Juan Soto’s $765MM Deal with the New York Mets, Record-Breaking Numbers, Opt-Out Details & More | 45

Welcome to Episode 45 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve are here to break down the deal that has sent shockwaves through baseball: Juan Soto’s record-shattering 15-year, $765MM contract with the New York Mets. In a move that will be talked about for decades, the Mets have outbid the Yankees and Red Sox to secure one of the game’s most transcendent hitters, forever changing the course of their franchise. We dive deep into the stunning details of the deal—no deferrals, a massive $75MM signing bonus, and the unique opt-out clause that could push this contract to an unprecedented $805MM. How did Steve Cohen’s Mets pull this off, and what went wrong for the Yankees, who let Soto slip away after he helped lead them to an AL pennant? For a franchise that has spent years chasing its next title, losing out on Soto may be a bitter pill to swallow, and we explore what this means for the Yankees' future plans. But this moment is about Soto’s greatness—a generational hitter whose elite plate discipline and all-around excellence make him a once-in-a-lifetime talent. At just 26 years old, Soto’s already legendary career enters its prime in Queens, where he joins Francisco Lindor to form a lineup that could rival the league’s very best. Is this the Mets’ version of Soto and Judge 2.0, and can this duo push New York’s other team to its first title since 1986? We also look ahead: the Mets aren’t done yet. With questions surrounding Pete Alonso’s free agency, needs in the starting rotation, and a bullpen to address, Steve Cohen’s war chest is still open for business. What happens next, and how does the rest of the league—especially the Yankees—respond to this monumental shift in power? It’s a franchise-altering deal, a crushing blow for their crosstown rivals, and the beginning of a new era for the Mets. Don’t miss this can’t-miss emergency episode. Follow us for exclusive content, breaking updates, and more:
📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod
🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod

Guest: Anthony DiNardo (North Shore Nine Podcast) | Pirates Offseason Plans, Rotation Talk, O'Neill Cruz's Transition to CF, & the Future of Bryan Reynolds | 44

Welcome to Episode 44 of Tablesetters, your go-to podcast for all things baseball! Hosts Devin and Steve are thrilled to be joined by Anthony DiNardo, lifelong Pirates fan and host of the North Shore Nine podcast, for a deep dive into the latest developments surrounding Pittsburgh baseball.
In this episode, we break down the non-tendering of Bryan de la Cruz and Connor Joe, the Pirates' promising pitching rotation featuring Paul Skenes, Mitch Keller, and Jared Jones, and the future of O'Neill Cruz as he transitions to center field. We also discuss Bryan Reynolds' rumored move to first base, the crowded catcher situation with Henry Davis, Joey Bart, and Endy Rodríguez, and the potential impact of recent roster decisions on the team's future. Plus, Anthony shares his take on the growing calls for Bob Nutting to sell the team.
Join us for an insightful conversation on what the Pirates need to do in the offseason to compete for the division and take the next step toward playoff contention in 2025.
Follow us for exclusive content and updates: 📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod
🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
Support the show: Like, subscribe, and share to help us grow!

MLB’s Golden At-Bat Rule, Blake Snell’s Dodgers Deal & Rays Stadium Uncertainty, Soto’s Free Agency & More | 43

Welcome to Episode 43 of Tablesetters! Devin and Steve kick things off with MLB’s new Golden At-Bat rule proposal, which could radically change the game’s strategy. This potential rule allows teams to bring up a batter of their choosing in key moments, even if that player isn’t due up yet—would this be a benefit to shake up late-game scenarios? We also dive into Blake Snell’s massive new deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers. The Cy Young winner has signed a five-year, $182 million contract, adding major firepower to the Dodgers’ already impressive rotation. What does this mean for LA’s World Series repeat hopes? Next, we take a close look at the ongoing stadium saga for the Tampa Bay Rays. After the team’s latest letter to Pinellas County, could the Rays be on the brink of leaving Tampa Bay? We break down the situation and what this uncertainty means for the team’s future. Plus, we cover the latest on Juan Soto’s free agency, with several major teams still vying for his services, and the Mets’ addition of Frankie Montas to their pitching staff as they continue to build for 2025. All that and more in this packed episode—don’t miss out! Follow us for exclusive content: 📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod 🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod

Red Sox Push for Soto | Blind Rankings: Worst Trade Hypotheticals | Kikuchi to Angels | Royals-Reds Trade | 42

Welcome to Episode 42 of Tablesetters! Before we dive in, a quick note: this episode was recorded before Blake Snell signed a 5-year, $182 million deal with the Dodgers on Tuesday night, so we’ll save our thoughts on that blockbuster for next time!
This week, Devin and Steve break down the Red Sox’s aggressive offseason plans. Boston is making a strong push for Juan Soto, while also targeting top free agents like Corbin Burnes and Max Fried, and considering a potential infield shuffle with Willy Adames. The Sox are serious about competing in 2025, but will Soto be their cornerstone? Devin has fun with the drama, pointing out how Soto is trolling the baseball world with cryptic moves.
We then dive into a major trade between the Royals and Reds, with Kansas City sending Brady Singer to Cincinnati for Jonathan India and Joey Wiemer. The Reds strengthen their rotation, while the Royals get two young, versatile players to help fuel their rebuild. We also discuss the Angels' signing of Yusei Kikuchi to a three-year, $63 million deal, hoping the lefty can stabilize their rotation for a 2025 playoff push.
In other news, we look at notable non-tenders like Dylan Carlson and Nick Madrigal, who could be looking for fresh opportunities. Meanwhile, Walker Buehler turns down interest from the A’s, citing concerns over their temporary home in Sacramento.
We also talk about KBO star Hyeseong Kim, who’s set to enter the MLB market via the posting system, drawing attention for his elite contact skills, speed, and defense.
For a fun twist, Devin and Steve tackle some of the worst trade ideas they've seen on Twitter in this week's Blind Rankings. And speaking of wild ideas, we discuss whether the 4th of July could become baseball’s version of Thanksgiving—an annual tradition to make baseball the go-to sport for America’s birthday.
Plus, we answer mailbag questions on budget free agents and when the first domino of the offseason will fall, and reflect on what we’re thankful for in the baseball world this year.
Don’t miss this jam-packed episode—grab your headphones and join the conversation!
Follow us for exclusive content and updates:📸 Instagram: @TablesettersPod🐦 Twitter: @TablesettersPod
Support the show: Like, subscribe, and share to help us grow!